top of page

Why one email rarely wins a B2B contract

Sep 1
4 min read

Erica Fraser, Founder of Withers & Sloane, writes on one of the most common misconceptions she sees in B2B marketing: the belief that a single email should be enough to win a client. Drawing on seven years of building marketing teams and commercial growth infrastructure for businesses across sectors, she explains what the buying journey looks like in practice and why email campaigns only work when they are planned as part of a wider system.



Many people outside marketing assume a single email will turn a cold prospect into a client. A campaign goes out, the reply rate comes back low, and within a fortnight the channel is written off as something that does not work for the business.

In practice, a B2B contract tends to follow twelve or more touchpoints over several months. Many of the moments that matter most are led by the buyer, out of your sight, and never appear in a campaign report. Judging email on a single send misreads how buying decisions are made.


What the buying journey looks like

A realistic B2B journey runs for around six months and moves through distinct phases. The timings vary by sector and deal size, but the pattern holds across most of the businesses we work with.

  1. Awareness, weeks 1 to 4. A prospect scrolls past a LinkedIn post, ignores your first email and opens the second without replying. Your name starts to register, often because a peer mentions you.

  2. Consideration, weeks 5 to 10. They visit your website and leave without filling in a form. A retargeting ad brings them back, they download a guide and become a known lead, then share a case study with colleagues.

  3. Decision, weeks 11 to 24. A buying group researches you together, often six to ten people. A discovery call confirms the problem, a proposal surfaces objections, and the contract follows at touch twelve or later.



The first email sits at touch two. It plays a part, and it is a long way from the finish line.


The moments you never see

Around half the touch points in that journey are led by the buyer. A peer recommendation over lunch and a buying group comparing notes in a meeting you are not invited to can shape the decision more than any campaign.


Neither shows up as a reply or a click attributed to your email. Both are still the result of your marketing, usually a LinkedIn post that made your name familiar or a case study worth forwarding. When a team only measures what it can see, it underrates the work doing the heaviest lifting.


What the first email is for

The first email still matters. Its job is to introduce you and make every later touch feel familiar, so the follow-ups land with someone who already recognises your name.

Written with that job in mind, it gets shorter and more useful. It might point to a relevant piece of content or make one clear observation about the prospect's market. Expecting it to carry the whole sale on its own makes a working campaign look like a failing one.


Planning the whole system

Planning an email campaign well means looking at your whole marketing infrastructure and understanding how each part works with the others. When we build outreach with clients, we map the full sequence before any copy is written.

  • Positioning first. Every touch repeats one clear message, so a prospect hears the same story whichever channel they meet you in.

  • Content between sends. Case studies and practical guides give prospects a reason to come back and something worth sharing internally.

  • Visibility on LinkedIn. Regular posts from the business and its leaders keep your name familiar during the weeks when nobody replies.

  • Shared definitions with sales. Sales and marketing agree in advance what an engaged account looks like and when it is ready for a conversation.

With those pieces in place, each email becomes one step in a planned journey and the campaign can be judged on how accounts move through it.


Measuring the journey

Reply rate on a single send tells a leadership team very little. A board needs to see whether target accounts are moving closer to a decision over the months it takes to close.

The measures worth tracking follow the journey: the number of target accounts engaging with your content and the value of pipeline marketing has created or influenced. Reported the same way every month, these show momentum building long before the first contract is signed, and they give the campaign the time it needs to work.


Plan for twelve touch points, then write the first email

B2B buyers take their time, and most of their journey happens where you cannot watch it. The businesses that win more contracts plan for that reality and build the infrastructure to support every stage of it.


Withers & Sloane provides senior fractional marketing leadership to help businesses build that system and report on it with confidence. If your pipeline depends on outreach that stops after one or two emails, we would be glad to take a look with you. Get in touch at info@witherssloane.com or visit witherssloane.com.


 
 
 

Comments


Post: Blog2_Post

©2026 by Withers & Sloane.

bottom of page